SeaKnots

I had an exciting couple of hours on Friday when sailing.  The boat was on starboard and sailing at 8+Knots, when went below and stepped into the cabin the water was up to the floorboards   A check of all of the thru hull fittings revealed all was well so turned for home and the nearest travel lift.  Once we were on an even keel the water level started to go down and a crew member on the manual pump provided extra capacity.

Once back on the dock  ( next to the travel lift) I started to investigate and when the 46 is on starboard the outlets for the bilge and shower bilge are underwater.  My boat has an anti-siphon loop in the pipe but no valve so water was coming back in through the shower bilge outlet.

Has anyone else experience this with the Oceanis?   I am going to fit anti-siphon valve and bilge alarm in any case but I think it should have been something the manufacturer shoul have accounted for.  If we had been on starboard for another 30-40 minutes the water would have flooded my battery banks and then we would have had a serious problem.

Views: 559

Replies to This Discussion

We have a 2008 43 and fortunately have not seen your issue. Bet that hit the max on your pucker scale though.

Mike

It was an exciting few hours to say the least.  Fortunate in that i was only 3-4 miles offshore and knew there was a travellift I could (hopefully) get to.   The dealer has sent an inquiry to Beneteau so if we get a reply I will post it here.

 

I've been searching for a small leak for the past 4 years.  The shower seal between the drain pan and shower floor was one leak.

 

Stephen I had one other source of water in the bilge from the AC unit in the salon. While there is a condensation pump the overflow tube would sometimes dumb water into the bilge. Unfortunately the hose was rather short and dumped it in the bilge compartment next to the mast post. I added a length of hose and routed it to the bilge sump. Another source of water at the AC unit can result if the compressor ices up. It can happen if there's not enough air flow through the duct work. Turning on the heat melts it quickly but the water drips off the compressor missing the catch pan. It finds it was through the floor boards into the same compartment I mentioned above.

Mike

I gave an report my designed sump drain system in an earlier SeaKnots.  Here it is:

I throw away the condensation pan pumps. When the water gets to the level for the pump to work, it had started to drain into the bilge by way of the pan overflow pipe.  I took an 9”x10”x7” high clear plastic food container with lid and connected the over flow to its side.  Placed a West Marine 12 volt automatic sump in the box.  Connected the old pan discharge hose to the sump pump.  I wired an on/off/intermittent switch.  Did the for both ac pans, no more water in bilge.  The sump pump comes on every 2 minutes and checks for head pressure for 10 seconds.  When I’m away and the ac is not on, I turn off the pumps. 

The leak I've been looking for is gone.  I got back from a 70 nm offshore race with steady 25 to 29 knot wonds gusting to 35, seas 4 to 6', 6 second intervals on the aft quarter and abeam. after beam run and close reach returning.  No water in the bilge and bone dry.

Go to http://seaknots.ning.com/group/beneteau4043/forum/topics/b40-advice for my 

Reply by Stephen Hegyesi on August 16, 2011 at 9:44pm

RSS

Latest Activity

John Hanrahan commented on CAN DRAC's group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Hi Everyone, Just grabbed a mooring at Man-O-War in the Abaco.  Great sail in 30knt winds the boat stands up well.  I did notice when I went below that there is a foam backed plastic apron in the forward cabin that covers the screw nails…"
Thursday
Gilles Picard posted a status
"My boat will be back to the Marina by the end of May and i wish you all a very good sailing season."
Apr 29
Simo Makkonen replied to sail abroad's discussion Sanitation hose BO40 in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"The two hoses you mentioned have probably been replaced more than 5 yrs ago, the hose to the bowl was changed 4 yrs ago. Somebody advised me to use seawater vaseline in the joints - easier to install and also remove next time. By the way, most…"
Apr 29
sail abroad replied to sail abroad's discussion Sanitation hose BO40 in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"thanks again for your reply. much appreciated. sounds like a bit of  mission but I guess we need to do it as the pipe really smells. How long since you changed the pipe on your boat? "
Apr 29
sail abroad replied to sail abroad's discussion Sail Sizes and Types for Beneteau 40 (2009) in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Hi Simo, thanks for your reply and all your info. We do already have the flatbar you describe, it came with the boat (we are 2nd owners). "
Apr 29
Will is now a member of SeaKnots
Apr 28
Simo Makkonen replied to Simo Makkonen's discussion Beneteau Oceanis 40 freshwater tank in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Thanks. Unfortunately I had to remove the tank for repair.The material is PE. Finally got the PE hot air welding rods from Germany and got it fixed. (Tried first with HDPE rods but the melting temp difference was to high.)"
Apr 27
Simo Makkonen replied to sail abroad's discussion Sanitation hose BO40 in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Hard PVC is not safe and is not approved by the safety regulations. I had the same problem and had to order it from France. Installation is tricky: you have to remove the tank, fit the new tube into tank, heat and pre-bend it, install the tank with…"
Apr 27
ADVERTISE ON SEAKNOTS CONTACT US AT: SeaKnots@SeaKnots.com

© 2015   Created by CAN DRAC.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service