SeaKnots

Sharing experience.

Windlass on my B40 stopped working unexpectedly and for no obvious reason. Tested everything and all seemed to be good.

Had had the same unexplained fault on a previous Beneteau, to repair I connected the center ground connection on the control side of the relay to the battery stud in the bow rather than relying on the small diameter wire running back aft to the battery.

And - same again, like magic once this 6" wire added my windlass sprang back to life. The B40 is only  three years old, no obvious signs of corrosion or breaks in the wiring harness. Can only think this circuit is boarder-line from the factory and once a little life gets taken into consideration some resistance in the factory harness builds up and the relay simply won't work.

Would love to hear from anyone who might have insight into same and my non technical fix is troubling me!

Views: 1215

Replies to This Discussion

Greg

It seems like control relay failure. The control relay is mounted on the engine just behind the alternator (that's the case on B43).  It is a small box (aprox 2,5x2,5x2,5 cm) which is grounded to the dynamo. Check the cables; the yellow one might be loose or you need to change the relay. 

Arne

Arne

Thanks. Windlass relay on my B40 is in the bow in the forepeak under the fwd berth. I agree, yellow earth cable that runs back aft to the battery isolator switch seems to have a fault. Relay working fine since I provided a good ground / 0v return path.

Greg, Interesting. My 2008 B40 windlass has worked flawlessly.. but its a bit of a marina queen. 

Arne, Is this (green box) the windlass control relay? I assume this is what acts as an interlock to keep the windlass from working without the motor running?

Harry

Harry

That's the box I was thinking of. It's not the windlass relay, but the relay or switch that controls the feed of 12V to the control side of the relay under the berth in the forepeak. This is probably the weakest point of the windlass installation. If this switch fail, one can steal power to the control side of the relay under the berth from one of the bow thruster batteries. The windlass will then act as normal, but it should only be a temp solution.

Arne

I do have this little green box hanging off the back of my alternator. It's actually under one of the mounting screws. However, my windlass will run without the engine running so in my instance this thing does not sense power coming from the alternator before allowing power to the windless.
As I am still unaware of the root on my problem am not ruling this out, just still thinking it's a high resistance issue on the yellow control cable. (but happy to be proved wrong)

thanks Harry / Arne.

You've likely solved the problem. Although not tested it ould certainly appear that this "engine running" control relay is the faulty item. My wiring in a by-pass negative control line has proved all other items good, and obviously by-passed the requirement for the engine to be running. 

I had a fault on the alternator a month ago where the main +ve output stud nut came loose and actually fell off the stud altogether. Retained in the red boot, (clearly shown in the photo sent by Harry). Arcing destroyed the stud and I had to replace same. Possible that the windlass control relay suffered damage at this time. (NB, crimp on the +ve battery lead attached to this stud had a 3/8" hole, stud is 3/16", crap job by installer.)

Thanks for help both.

Had the windlass fail to operate a couple of years ago. All I go was a click like you hear on a car when the battery is dead. Found that the 300a fuse on the house battery had corrosion on the faces which caused enough of a voltage drop to prevent the windlass from running. There was enough juice to activate the relay which explains the clicking noise.

Mike

When you say you checked all the fuses and breakers did you check them with an ohmeter or did you read the voltage on the input then output side of each device? If you didn't do voltage checks recheck every connection, fuse, breaker, common terminals, components, etc. Best to start at the charger then work through every switch, isolator, fuse, etc.  You should see 12+ volts at the charger. Once you find the 10.1V then you've found the source of the volatge drop.

Good luck

Mike

The thruster only working with the engine turned on is normal, the windlass works the same way. I believe it's wired that way to keep people from running thier battery down if not connected to shore power. The 110ac charger is connected to all the batteries and according to the schematic the thruster battery is tied in to the charger via one of the isolators. If you're only getting 10.1V and the charger is on then there has to be a voltage drop somewhere. If you want to check the isolator just check the voltage from the charger at the input to the isolator, then output voltage from the isolator. You should have almost the same reading, maybe a couple of tenths lower on the output. Dont forget to check the connections on the isolator for looseness or corrosion. If you still cant find the problem call in someone for help, be it a friend experienced with boat electrics or a professional. I'd also contact your Beneteau Service Manager for their recommendations. Perhaps there is a unique manner in which the system works.

On my B43 (European model),the thruster batteries are only beeing charged by the engine alternator.

Arne

Steve, on delivery my thruster was only bring charged by the alternator. I added a wire from the third leg output on the 110 v charger to the output side of the solid state isolator that feeds the thruster. Now, when at dock on shore power the thruster battery gets a full replenishment. Where we sail, we seldom motor long enough to get an adequate and full charge on engine alone. Also,  had one of the two isolators die early on and had it replaced.

Sam

Longhawk

great timing. my windlass just stopped working last weekend. i checked the likely suspects, breaker switch that has gone out on me once already, and the handheld remote switch that i also had to replace. i'll be back on the boat soon and will let you guys know if any of the great suggestions below help my problem. oh, are those relays available at typical marine stores like west marine? or do you have to order them off the web? anybody know the specs? i'm currently on land.

btw, last year, the breaker kept tripping upon using the windlass. a good cleaning with degreaser, a lot of elbow grease and real greasing of the windlass made a big difference. it was clogged with salt deposits and crud and most of the grease was gone. we anchor a lot.

/clay

RSS

Latest Activity

sail abroad added a discussion to the group Beneteau 40 & 43
Thumbnail

Beneteau 40 2008 replacement rudder bearings

Has anyone replaced the rudder bearings on a beneteau 40 2008/9? If someone has done this job could they please tell me what the part numbers are for both the bronze upper and lower bearing sleeves and also for the nylon thrust washers. The jefa? rudder shaft diameter is 60mm.I have !ooked on the beneteau spare parts website without success.Also I am trying to find the workshop notes for rep!acing the bearings as I know with the oceanis 411 the bottom bearing is glued (3M 5200) in but I don't…See More
32 minutes ago
sail abroad liked GaryG's discussion B40 jib upgrade
48 minutes ago
Mike Brown replied to Wayne's discussion New B 40 owner. in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Wayne, welcome to the group. I think you'll find a wealth of information from all the members. And of course enjoy your B40, its a heck of a boat. Mike October Moon 2008 B43"
Thursday
MAssimiliano replied to MAssimiliano's discussion foldng prop FOF on beneteau 40 in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Hi Michael, at the moment I prefer a Folding Prop due to better performance while sailing and also when "motoring". My gearbox has a ratio in forwarding of 2.36. don't worry... I'm not American....I'm Italian :-) "
Thursday
Michael Boyle replied to MAssimiliano's discussion foldng prop FOF on beneteau 40 in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Hi, I have a Kiwi feathering prop on my Beneteau 43, 4JH5E engine. It looks small and blades are a funny shape but it works perfectly. They set the pitch depending on size of engine, will need to know gearbox ratios, and it has full pitch in reverse…"
Thursday
MAssimiliano added a discussion to the group Beneteau 40 & 43
Thumbnail

foldng prop FOF on beneteau 40

Hi, This is my first post in the group and first of alll I want to say Hi at all. I have a Ben 40 with a yanmar 3jh4e (40cv) and I am thinking to buy a flexofold propeller. They suggest me a 18x13R. Have anyone experience with this boat and propeller in terms of sailing performance and boat speed under engine? Do you have data for  boat speed at various RPM? Thanks. Best of all for everyone.See More
Thursday
Profile IconMAssimiliano and Wayne joined CAN DRAC's group
Thumbnail

Beneteau 40 & 43

A place to exchange thoughts, ideas and discussions about the Beneteau/Oceanis 40 and 43 models.
Thursday
Wayne added a discussion to the group Beneteau 40 & 43
Thumbnail

New B 40 owner.

Hello all,Will take delivery of my '08 B40 9/27/16 and joined this forum. I look forward to the enjoyment of the boat and exchanging info here. Will be on the ICW in south Alabama.Happy SailingSee More
Thursday
ADVERTISE ON SEAKNOTS CONTACT US AT: 
candrac@sailforwater.com

© 2016   Created by CAN DRAC.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service