SeaKnots

Question to fellow seaknoters:  I have an opportunity to purchase a ManOverBoard Rescue System at a good price, my question is, in as mush as I have a step-off dive platform would this be a wast of money?

Views: 192

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If you mean a hoisting rig, it might be a good investment. The dive platform does no good if the MOB is unconcious or injured. Also depends on what you consider a good price.

I have a Lifesling 2.  It is not the inflatable type and if/ when I need it, its right on the stern rail.  Because of the newer inflatables,  the prices has dropped to about $125 (half of what I paid) so that's a deal.  This is definitely not a waste of money when a life is involved.  Larry is correct about unconscious MOB's.. problem is,  the only thing you can do in that case is get close enough to haul them aboard and some sort of hoisting rig is almost mandatory as hauling up even someone who weighs even 100 lbs requires incredible strength.  You should note that if you get a Lifesling or something similar,  if you don't remove them when you aren't on the boat,  they can 'disappear', so stow 'em when not out on the water.

If you don't sail offshore you don't really need it. BUT, offshore the problem is trying to find someone overboard. With large swells and blown out wind waves you just can't see a head bobbing in the water. A ring w/ a line and pole are a must. I would say get it bought. just my two cents and 50,000 nm experence.. Michael..

Don't depend on dive platform. No good if victim panics, injured, in heavy seas, poor swimmer, etc. Lifesling very good and USCG approved. Rig boom for hoisting victims with winch help. PRACTICE mob maneuvers and rescue procedures preferably with a live volunteer. Cannot over emphasize practice !

mob systems work great for short handing and crewed sailing. they dont work so well for solo sailors....is difficult to deploy it when yer overboard--might be better for a solo sailor to  tether properly.  but if you are going to any crewed sailing   or shorthanding, is an excellent idea.

I don't have an MOB system as usually I sail solo.  At night or during the day if things get nasty always have my harness on or in the cockpit ready to put on so I can tether myself to my boat.    If I have a guest(s) aboard who are non-sailors. I normally keep closer to shore & never take them out if WX seems could be nasty. If that should happen, non-sailors are definitely difficult to deal with while still trying to handle the boat...don't need that.  Plus my kittties are aboard....hmm... that would be a huge decision!!!!   I have to question if a swim platform is much help in an emergency as you still need to get them to the platform first + then getting someone out of the water can be another real issue depending on their condition & if they are even able to assist you.  If this is of help... if I am solo or have an experienced sailor with me & the WX should turn nasty, I throw 150 feet of line to drag behind, have put large knots in this line every 5 feet to make it easier to grab/hang onto to pull oneself back to the boat,  have the swimladder rigged to get it down easily if I would find myself or crew in the water w/o banging someone or (me) on the head + have a Handi Lift System on the stern rail for putting my outboard engine on the dinghy which is supposed to lift up to 200lb (if someone is over 200 lb. then we would have another huge problem)   Of course for the Handi Lift System there must be someone onboard to work the pulley system. Depending on where you are sailing & the level of sailing expertise of the people you have aboard.......you should think less about the cost than the most effective method of the system you decide on.  Ultimately, the responsiblity of all aboard your boat rests on you.  There is loads of information out there on the net...seems you just need to do your due diligence....think through all the advice, suggestions from others.....is not easy.   Good luck with your decision.....

not a waste of money.   your platform will not reach out to someone who falls off the bow or side of the boat.  

RSS

Latest Activity

Michael Mc Laughlin is now a member of SeaKnots
9 hours ago
zeehag commented on zeehag's blog post take two......
"engine is now rebuilt and   requires merely the fine tuning  an d  such   the mechanic  wants and  needs to do. he also knows a  tank  builder  so we can pursue our  desired fg   increased…"
9 hours ago
zeehag posted a status
"still post runaway diesel and seize. HOWEVER, rebuild done. we be headed to other repair ports shortly, after new fg tank, etc"
9 hours ago
Ken Mcarthur joined Franc's group
Thumbnail

Sailors with guitars

Ever notice how many sailors carry guitars on board? If you are one of those, join this group, tell us what you play and don't forget to invite other SeaKnot friends to your next cockpit performance!
Friday
Ken Mcarthur joined h's group
Thumbnail

Maps maps everywhere

Link to maps that are available on the internet world
Friday
Marlene Anne Sassaman left a comment for Stephen
"Hi Stephen, Wow, Reno, Nevada! My mate and I had lunch in Reno about a year ago while on a cross country tent camping trip. My blog is so long in need of an update. I will read it over tonight and conjure up a recap. I can't remember off hand…"
Thursday
Marlene Anne Sassaman left a comment for Karyn Miller
"Hi Karyn, I am finally catching up on Sea Knots and my other writings. It has been an interesting past few months on land while transitioning to another sea adventure. Coincidently I will be in Melbourne area this week-end. Saturday and Sunday is…"
Wednesday
GaryG replied to GaryG's discussion Navionics Platinum Plus in the group Beneteau 40 & 43
"Got it. Thanks.  I was hoping to find presentation similar to the Navionics iPad app, but the Platimun plus is a generation behind the iPad app, and not worth the cost, in my opinion"
Wednesday
ADVERTISE ON SEAKNOTS CONTACT US AT: SeaKnots@SeaKnots.com

© 2014   Created by CAN DRAC.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service